6 How Surface and Deep Learning Works

Everyone can learn and you are learning all the time. How can you apply this to your studies?

You Choose Your Approach to Learning[1]

Approaches to learning describe what you do when you are learning and why you should do it. The basic distinction is between a Deep approach to learning, where you are aiming towards understanding that allows you to use and reuse the information in a variety of situations, and a Surface approach to learning, where you are primarily memorizing material for the tests and exams. Deep and Surface approaches are not attributes of individual learners. You may use both approaches at different times, although you may have a preference for one or the other in some circumstances.

These terms do correlate fairly closely with your motivation: deep with self (intrinsic) motivation and surface with external (extrinsic) motivation, but are not necessarily the same thing. Either approach can be used by a person with either type of motivation.

A surface approach is useful when you are in the early stages of learning new material as there will always be terminology and formulas to be acquired along with basic concepts to be learned and practised until they become embedded and reflexive. When you are studying material that you know will be an integral part of your profession in the future, you will want to concentrate on deeper approaches where the context and connections become more complex over time.

These are the basic steps in the process of learning:

  1. An increase in knowledge by acquiring individual pieces of information.
  2. Memorizing, storing, and retrieving information that can be reproduced.
  3. Acquiring facts, skills, and methods that can be retained and used as necessary.
  4. Making sense and meaning – this involves relating parts of the subject matter to each other and to real world situations.
  5. Constructing mental maps in different ways understanding the subjects by re-interpreting knowledge in numerous combinations.

The trick is not to think that the first three (surface) steps are all that you need. They are the foundation that you will use to build your deep understanding in higher steps (4 & 5) through course activities applied with personal analysis and thoughtfulness.

Information Gathering Memorize, Store Information Application, Methods to Use Info Relationships in the World Constructing Many Combinations
Image Credit: Alice Macpherson

Deep Learning
– work towards incorporating

Surface Learning
– use to bridge to deep learning

Definitions

Examining new facts and ideas critically, and tying them into existing cognitive structures and making numerous links between ideas. Knowledge transforming.

Accepting new facts and ideas uncritically and attempting to store them as individual, unconnected, items. Information reproducing.

Features

Looking for meaning.
Focusing on the central argument or concepts needed to solve a problem. Interacting actively and critically with content knowledge.
Distinguishing between argument and evidence.
Making connections between different modules.
Relating new and previous knowledge. Linking course content to real life.

Seeing course content as material to be learned for the exam.
Vocabulary building relies on memorization.
Focusing only on the formulae needed to solve a problem.
Receiving information as fact.
Not distinguishing principles from examples.
Treating modules/chapters and courses as separate.
Not yet seeing how new material builds on previous work.

How to Apply

Have an intrinsic curiosity in the subject.
Be determined to do well and mentally engaged when doing academic work. Learn the appropriate background knowledge for a sound foundation in the discipline.
Positive experience of education leads to confidence in ability to understand and succeed.
Intend to understand material for yourself.
Critically interact with content knowledge.
Relate ideas to your previous knowledge and experience.
Discover and use organizing principles to integrate ideas.
Relate evidence to conclusions. Examine the logic of arguments.

Issues arise when you stop here:

• Study only for individual exams.
• Missing the focus on professional applications.
• Lacking background knowledge and understanding.
• Often not enough time / too high a workload.
• Believing that factual recall is all that is required.
• Is associated with high anxiety.
• Not reflecting on purpose or strategies.
• Memorize facts and procedures routinely without looking at context.
• Not distinguishing guiding principles or patterns.

Questions:


  1. (Compiled from Biggs (1999), Entwistle (1988) and Ramsden (1992) and adapted from http://exchange.ac.uk/learning-and-teaching-theory-guide/deep-and-surface-approaches-learning.html )

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

On Track for Success in Trades Programs Copyright © 2021 by Kwantlen Polytechnic University is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book